Google+ A Tangled Rope

Friday, August 17, 2007

Can Blue Men Sing The Whites?

John Harris on The Guardian’s CiF wants to bury one myth: that Elvis was a racist and his music was 'stolen' from black America.

My Comment:

More to the point is that people can define 'racism' almost any way they want, and saying it loudly enough about someone famous or something in the news gets them far more attention (with, however, the concomitant danger that they may be trampled in the stampede to mount the bandwagon by others equally eager to join in) than saying something reasonable, say, as in this case how the original blues and country artists lost out during the invention of rock 'n' roll.
And, yes, Big Mama Thornton's Hound Dog is better. But there is also an Elvis album where he do the blues (can't remember what it is called - Reconsider Baby(?)) where he shows he could do it and do it well.

Wednesday, August 15, 2007

Doth Protest Too Much

Zoe Williams on The Guardian’s CiF shows some solidarity with the self-styled ‘eco-protestors’ currently grooving it up in a typically smug self-congratulatory manner in a field near some aeroplanes.

My comment:

Of course, irritating, inconveniencing, berating and annoying ordinary people trying to go about their normal lives up to and beyond the point where they refuse to listen to what you have to say out of sheer bloody-mindedness may - just - in the end be slightly counter-productive.

The best way would be to make your case through argument and debate and appealing to people's good sense in a positive and constructive way rather than berating them, however this later course can be deeply unsatisfying to those truly committed to their cause as it tends to lack he smug self-satisfied feeling of martyrdom.

Protesters should also be made aware that over-the-top zealotry tends to make people very suspicious of you as a person, rather than drawing attention to the cause you are espousing - as can be seen from some responses to this story here and elsewhere about 'work-shy layabouts' and so on.

In short, protesting may make you feel good, but in the words of your teachers when you were at school: 'it is your own time you are wasting.'

Kids These Days

I still don't have time to do 'proper' blogging. But I thought I'd go back to reprinting here the comments I have made on various MSM sites as a way of easing myself back into the groove – as it were.

Anyroadup. Guardian CIF has this from Cheshire police about the tragic death of Garry Newlove.

My comment:

There are two ways - or rather, two strand - that societies keep order: the formal - police, laws and so on, and the informal - the community, families etc.

In the UK, over the last few decades, it seems both of these strands have been eroded. The police and the law system have been slowly strangled by bureaucratic managerialism, including such things as targets, increasing emphasis on 'defensive' actions to avoid legal counter-claims, the need to document everything a police officer does and so on.

A similar thing has happened in the informal realm where adults feel they no longer have any authority over younger folks at all. I can remember when I was young even frail old pensioners would feel justified in telling me off for even wheeling my bike on the pavement, let alone daring to ride it on the pavement.

There was a recent thread here about the police restraining some drunk woman and I recall one commenter said something like 'the trouble is the police use too much force.'

Thinking about it later I came to the conclusion that it is in fact the opposite that is true - the police, adults too, no longer have the option of forcing youngsters to behave. Yes, the good old 'clip 'round the ear' (mainly as a vague unfulfilled threat, of course). But - like teachers too -losing the power of such instant summary justice means that problems are not nipped in the bud, children are not learning at a relatively young age that certain behaviours overstep the mark and - as a consequence - are slipping further and further out of control until it gets too late for them as well as for us.

Thursday, August 09, 2007

September Song

If there is anyone still bothering to read this, sorry for the lack of new stuff. But - at the moment - I don't really have anything I want to do here.
Maybe I will return in September when I have more time, if not I think I will give up on this completely.

Monday, July 16, 2007

Monday Poem: Circumnavigation

Circumnavigation

Can your small room take the place
of a whole wide world?

Can you walk the arid deserts
of this threadbare carpet?

Can you explore the jungles
of all these dense memories,

then climb the highest peaks
of this forgotten furniture?

Can you search out beyond the horizon
of these so solid walls

and see far enough to glimpse
the life you know you should have lived?



Wednesday, July 11, 2007

The End Of The Race?

I said in this that it was part of a longer piece. Well, in response to this CiF piece I’ve finally got around to tidying it up enough for this place too.

Maybe we should dump the notion of race altogether. Race as a concept maybe made a sort of simplistic sense in earlier times when travel between continents was difficult – which was the reason why separate ‘racial’ characteristics evolved over time, but nowadays with all the ‘races’ mixing together (and having children with each other) the concept grows increasingly more meaningless. Take, for example, the American Presidential candidate Barack Obama, Who is often described as black, even self-described as such, when he is mixed race, or by the same self-definition could call himself white. So, when race becomes a matter of you are what you say you are, it then loses whatever objective meaning it was once thought to have.

When the left adopted ‘race’ as one of its causes, naturally it saw it as a collectivist problem with – therefore - a collective solution. Rather than wasting away – just as the state was supposed to do under communism, we find that race and race ‘differences’ become accented and entrenched by what could be called the ‘race-relations’ industry – just as the state apparatus became stronger and stronger under communism.

You would have thought that after things like the Nazi’s ‘Final Solution’ and apartheid and all the ‘ethnic’ cleansing, people would begin to question this 19th Century notion of ‘the races’. Although – as this is a blog comment – I haven’t bothered to research it, I do seem to recall that there is little or no scientific, genetic, evidence for any significant differences between the races. It is literally only superficial, skin colour, different shaped noses etc and a few mostly minor differences that make someone more disposed towards, or immune to, a few medical conditions and that is it.

Anyway, a few months ago, a C4 programme analysed the DNA of various British people and discovered that far from being pure ‘white’ there were traces of DNA from all over the world, which probably makes the whole idea of ‘races’ as more or less homogeneous entities a bit of a nonsense too.

‘Multiculturalism is just another word for apartheid. Rather than creating ‘equality’, it has ossified divisions, stereotyping people into ghettos. More examples: Black actors complain of only being offered the roles of pimp or drug dealer, black (or other ethnicities) writers complain of being condemned to only write of the ‘black experience’ and so on. Personally, I find the whole ‘role-models’ theory, weak and unconvincing. However, putting those doubts to one side for a moment – why should a young black boy have all his options restricted to just ‘black role-models’?

This race business has also helped to develop ‘victim’ culture where every failing can be excused as the fault of ‘the system’ that is biased against them. It has become so successful at tapping ‘liberal guilt’ that now others vying for power and influence such as ‘the Muslim community’ are trying to extend the victim status of race into religion.

‘Identity’ (assuming that there is any meaning to this concept too) should not be imposed from outside – whether by antagonistic or benign forces, it should be created from within – deep within by the individual.

Maybe the answer is not treating people as groups – white, black, Muslims Catholics, women, lesbians or whatever, we should see them, treat them as individuals – not lock them in cages of created ‘identity’.

This article here (now subscription only) by Rod Liddle says a few related interesting things:

If you insist to black children that there is something about the colour of their skin which marks them out as fundamentally, rather than superficially, different and then insist that they are part of a culture from which they cannot — and should not wish to — escape, then you are tacitly driving them towards criminality. It is no good later shaking your heads and saying no, no, boys, I meant James Baldwin and Maya Angelou. You cannot have it both ways. It is also a quintessentially racist approach, in as far as I understand the term — although one which has underpinned the now discredited policy of multiculturalism for the best part of 40 years.

We should sweep it all away. All the discrimination, all the cant, all the misplaced attempts to instil pride in people simply because they have a greater (or, for that matter, lesser) amount of melanin. Why do we need award ceremonies, for example, like Mobo — Music of Black Origin? Why are there so many awards for black people in the media? Aren’t these little jamborees by their very definition racist? Don’t they perpetuate the notion that black people are in some way separate from the rest of us and, worse, that they should remain so? Why do our schools have a Black History Month every October? Shouldn’t the history of black people inform the subject every month of the year?

Tuesday, July 10, 2007

Monday Poem: Shoreline

This week’s special offer!

For one week only!

A Monday poem on Tuesday!

Shoreline


But those were early younger days.
So eager, waking with the dawn
and old enough to walk alone
on down to the deserted beach.

I never searched for shells or stooped
to pick out pebbles, choosing them
by shape or colour, leaving them
wherever they had washed ashore,
to be discovered by those who thought
such things important or worthwhile.

It was enough to stand and stare
towards the far horizon's end.
To see then, all that could be seen.
I wanted that cool salty tang
always there in my mouth and nose.

I stood there in the morning's cool
to look out over the still sea.
It seemed as flat and smooth as glass.
A sheet to touch the horizon.

But, other times it churned and writhed
in great pain or tormented hurt,
attempting to escape the chains
of gravity, as seeing clouds
above it floating free of weight,
it grew so jealous of their freedom.

I stood up on that cliff to watch
the hesitant bright-coloured specks
as people spread out on the beach
in pointillist bright waves across
the virgin sands. The way they took
the silence of the beach and grew
new waves of sound to fling right back
against the slow retreating sea.

Their tentative colonisation
of shore and then the sea, destroying
the reasons why I had just walked there.